Be The Captainvideo

The Preventer Mistake That Killed Two Sailors

December 22, 2025 · 15 min · 571K views

Sailboat at hull speed downwind under black sails

What this video covers

James Evenson, who anchored alongside Carl and Anne-Marie in Bermuda before their fatal June 2022 passage, reconstructs the loss of SV Escape — a CNB 66 — and extracts seven seamanship lessons from the disaster.0:25 Carl and Anne-Marie departed St. George's, Bermuda, bound for Nova Scotia with two experienced crew.1:12 Conditions deteriorated on the second night while crossing the Gulf Stream: wind built from the high teens into the mid-30s with gusts into the mid-40s, and wind-against-current stacked steep, short-period seas.2:10 To take a second reef, the crew turned head-to-wind — required by the CNB 66's in-boom electric furling system — and lost control of the boom in the violent motion.3:00 The mainsheet snapped taut and struck Anne-Marie; the boom swung back and compound-fractured Carl's leg; shock loading ripped the mainsheet fitting from the deck.3:55 Rescue swimmers dropped from a helicopter in darkness recovered both, but neither survived.5:30 The seven lessons: reef at sunset before conditions force it; sail at 80% capacity to preserve margin; treat wind-against-current zones like the Gulf Stream as categorically more dangerous than forecast; reef off the wind rather than head-to-wind whenever possible; distribute situational awareness and reefing procedures across the whole crew; match boat size to what the crew can actually manage in degraded conditions; and treat the first 72 hours of any passage as the highest-risk period.5:50 Evenson also references PredictWind for crew weather access and John Harries of Attainable Adventure Cruising for off-the-wind reefing technique.9:14

Watch on YouTube

More from Be The Captain

31 Crew Sailed Into Hurricane Mitch. None Were Ever Found | The Tragic Story of SV FantomeAug 2026Declared Dead at Sea — Then They Came Back | The Rose-Noëlle StoryJul 2026My Final Video as Sailing ZingaroJul 2026The Brutal Truth About Cruising on a Budget & Surviving Storms at SeaJul 2026

From Be The Captain — see the channel’s boat, crew, and every analyzed video.

The Sailing Directory Newsletter

One email with the fleet's best finds — the moments, boats, and stories worth your watch time. Enter your own address to get your own copy.

Report an issue